American Seasons

2011 Best Romantic Restaurant, Nantucket

The candlelit, farmhouse-style dining room will get you started, and a bottle from the all-American wine list will complete the effect. Chef Michael LaScola’s cuisine is well suited to sharing: Split a silky foie gras terrine with black Mission figs and a porterhouse chop big enough for two.

Most Viewed Winners of Cape & Islands

  • Boarding House, 2015 Best Brunch, Nantucket