Lucky Hank’s

2013 Best New Restaurant, Martha's Vineyard

You’ll feel like guests at a neighbor’s summer home here. The dining room is a screened-in back porch with pillow-covered bench seats and mismatched silverware, and homey dishes such as meatloaf and lobster potpie grace the dinner menu—as do three veggie sides (we loved the balsamic Brussels sprouts) sourced from what’s available on the island’s farms that day.

Most Viewed Winners of Cape & Islands

  • Millie’s, 2015 Best Bar, Nantucket